(15-25 min.) Decision Case 2
Req. 1
This question provides a rich setting for a class discussion. There’s no
single correct answer to this question. Some students may favor Company
B because it reports higher net income than Company A. B may be
preferred because it appears more successful than A, and B’s stock price
may therefore rise more than A’s stock price. Thus it may appear that
Company B would be a better investment than A.
Other students may prefer Company A because it discloses the inventory
method it uses. Company B does not let outsiders know which method it
uses to account for its inventory. These students may trust Company A
more than B because A is more willing to “bare its soul to the public.”
Professors can point out that A, the LIFO company, may be better off
because of the lower income taxes that A pays by using the LIFO method.
We don’t know whether Company B is making the most of this cash-flow
advantage of LIFO.
Student responses will vary.
Req. 2
Yes, the authors would prefer managers to be faithful in representing the
disclosures for inventory — for all the reasons accountants are transparent
and truthful. We would prefer that the financial statements present the
most economically realistic and honest picture of the way assets, liabilities,
revenue, and expenses are measured and reported. It is only then that
financial markets can operate in the way intended.